Apprendimento e performance nei contesti scolastici e sportivi: uno studio comparativo basato su vignette

Authors

  • Mariapia Mazzella Università degli studi di Cassino e del Lazio Meridionale
  • Arianna Fogliata Università Luigi Vanvitelli Caserta

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.7346/sird-1S2026-p129

Keywords:

Learning; Performance; Evaluation; Adaptation; Professional Judgment

Abstract

The recognition of learning is an interpretive process through which teachers and coaches assign meaning to the changes observed in learners and athletes. This study examines the criteria used in school and sport contexts to distinguish learning from mere performance.

Methods. A cross-sectional observational vignette-based study was conducted involving 113 professionals working in Lombardy, Italy, including 52 physical education teachers and 61 coaches. Participants evaluated four vignettes representing different configurations of performance, error awareness, autonomy, and adaptation. For each vignette, they rated the degree of learning attributed to the individual, the extent to which the observed outcome was considered representative of learning, and the perceived success of the educational activity.

Results. Teachers and coaches showed general convergence in attributing greater learning to situations characterised by awareness, autonomy, and adaptation. The main differences concerned the importance assigned to immediately observable outcomes. Coaches considered outcomes more representative of learning in situations involving immediate performance improvement, whereas teachers placed greater emphasis on exploration, strategy reorganisation, and increasing autonomy. Analysis of the discrepancy between attributed learning and the perceived representativeness of the outcome revealed different ways of interpreting evidence of learning. The largest differences emerged in judgments concerning the representativeness of the outcome.

Conclusions. The recognition of learning appears to be influenced both by the characteristics of the situations observed and by the professional cultures of teachers and coaches. These findings highlight the importance of assessment practices that integrate performance, process, and adaptation.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-18

How to Cite

Mazzella, M., & Fogliata , A. (2026). Apprendimento e performance nei contesti scolastici e sportivi: uno studio comparativo basato su vignette. ITALIAN JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH, 129–136. https://doi.org/10.7346/sird-1S2026-p129

Issue

Section

Researches

Categories